5 Myths About Pricing That Are Costing Your Clients Higher-Paying Projects

Shannon Mattern is a pricing expert and creator of The Package Matrix™ Method that helps freelancers, fractional execs, consultants, agencies and service providers stop undercharging, overdelivering and overworking by using pricing, proposal and sales strategies backed by behavioral economics and sales psychology.

Summary: How business coaches, consultants and group program leaders can help experienced professionals who’ve gone out on their own charge more on their very next proposal, without waiting until they’ve built case studies, thought leadership or a reputation first.


If you’re a business coach, consultant or run a business coaching program, your clients come to you because they want to grow their businesses and make more money without sacrificing their freedom.

…and yet when it comes to pricing, they often feel like a contestant on The Price Is Right, trying to figure out the highest number that a client will say yes to without going over and losing the sale.

You know they need to charge more. They know they need to charge more, and they’re absolutely willing to charge more…

But what’s about to get in their way, slow them down and make raising their prices take way longer than it needs to are 5 assumptions that most of us have about what’s required to charge higher prices:

  1. I need to start low to gain experience, pay my dues and work my way up and earn the right to charge more.
  2. When I get booked out at this price, then I can start raising my prices.
  3. I need the right messaging, positioning and branding before I can charge more.
  4. If I’m seen as an expert and thought leader in my industry, I can justify charging premium prices.
  5. Having a lot of case studies and testimonials will help me justify higher prices.

Every one of these comes back to the same belief we’ve all absorbed: that you have to hustle and look good to earn it.

But what if your clients don’t have to start low, get booked out at their current price first, build their thought leadership and be seen as an expert, have dialed-in messaging and positioning, or collect case studies and testimonials before they can charge more?

What if their consultation, proposal and sales process was strategically designed to empower them to charge more now, on their very next proposal?

And what if the proposal process they’re using now is unintentionally setting them up to charge less? To agonize over their price just to lower it one more time before hitting send?

What if you could help your clients change that, and they were able to charge more on their very next proposal?

How would having a pricing methodology that helped your clients start making more now make your job of helping your clients grow their businesses without sacrificing their freedom easier?

And what would it do for your client retention, renewals and referrals to have clients that were able to create results even faster?

In this post, I’ll walk you through why these myths are so easy to believe, how they’re slowing down your clients’ results (and maybe your own), what’s actually true, and what you can do differently starting with your clients’ very next proposal.

Let’s get into it.

Why “Start Low and Earn Your Way Up” Sounds So Logical

It’s the advice everyone has heard and most of us followed ourselves through trial and error on our own way up: find the going market rate for that role, start there, and raise your prices as you build your skills, brand, positioning, testimonials and thought leadership so you can prove your value.

It’s the same advice we got for climbing the corporate ladder:

“Pay your dues and earn the right to justify a higher salary.”

And we carried it straight into running a business without questioning it.

Many business coaching programs are built around niching, positioning, messaging, sales and marketing, with pricing left up to the client – the logical assumption being that they’ll choose a price that’s profitable and helps them reach their goals.

But that’s usually not the case. Without a clear pricing strategy, your clients look to see what their competitors are charging (without any context for whether their competitors’ businesses are working well or not).

And when they see well-known experts in their industry charging premium prices, and make the assumption that the visibility, credibility and thought-leadership caused the price, and think that’s what they have to do to charge more too.

The “Earn It First” Myth Is Slowing Down Your Clients’ Results

Because your clients were taught to believe they have to hustle to charge more, it’s taking them longer than necessary to create results.

When you’re silent on pricing and leave it up to your clients to decide or defer to conventional wisdom (or AI), they could implement pricing advice that’s not a good fit for their business model, or that conflicts with or works against your program or strategies.

Without a science-backed pricing strategy that you teach or help them implement, your clients go off in lots of different directions to make more money, solving the wrong problems and spending money they could be spending with you.

And every time they hear “That’s out of our price range…” they think “See, I knew my price was too high. If I had more testimonials…” which only makes the myth that they have to hustle and look good to earn it feel more true.

So they try to make up for it by proving their credibility through case studies and thought leadership and branding, messaging and positioning.

It’s like they have their foot on the gas and the brake at the same time, and instead of taking their foot off the brake to move forward, they’re pressing harder on the gas, which ultimately leads to burning out.

Meanwhile, the clients who started low end up with “legacy” clients paying their “starter” rates and taking up more time and energy than they’d like… plus the referrals that come from those clients tend to come in at that same low price which sends them down another rabbit hole of rebranding and repositioning to attract clients with bigger budgets – when they could have simply used a different pricing strategy in the first place.

And if you’re being really honest… you might be operating from this same myth in your own business!

Holding off on raising your program prices until you have more testimonials or visibility. Or adding more branding and marketing modules to your curriculum or consulting to fix what’s actually a pricing problem – which gives your clients more work to do without making their results any faster, when the truth is that your clients could charge more on their very next proposal with the business they have right now, today.

How I Solved This Problem For My Clients

I’ve seen this firsthand with my Web Designer Academy program that I started back in 2016.

For the first couple of years, I taught my students – who were experienced web designers wanting to grow their businesses, not newbies learning web design for the first time – to do what I did to grow my freelance web design business back in the day:

Hustle to build credibility as a web designer so they could charge more.

That hustle looked like content marketing that talked about their process, case studies, choosing a “lucrative” niche, going into groups and communities and sharing their knowledge and expertise, turning their own website into something a client would be impressed with…

You might be reading all of that and think “What’s wrong with that? It sounds like best practice.”

The problem was that “so that they could charge more” statement tacked on there at the end.

All that hustle was bringing them new leads and clients, but it didn’t necessarily translate into them feeling confident to charge what I knew they really could and should be charging.

They’d inch their way up in price until the moment they heard someone say “that’s out of my price range” – and that’s when their brains created a rule that said “no one will pay that much, this is the most you can charge” and I watched them undercharge, overdeliver and burn out.

And no amount of me telling them to “charge their worth” fixed it.

I found myself constantly coaching my students on helping them see the value they were creating for their clients, helping them sell themselves on their pricing, helping them understand what they were really selling, helping them communicate the value, helping them build the confidence to charge what they really wanted to be charging.

So I started attacking the pricing problem from every angle I could come up with:

  • A pricing calculator designed to help them figure out the minimum they needed to charge to reach their income goals (which gave them sticker shock).
  • A system for how to properly scope and price a project, including accounting for their overhead and accurately estimating their time (which gave them sticker shock).
  • Lessons on the difference between cost-based pricing and value-based pricing, and why they need to untie how much time it takes them from how much they charge (which gave them sticker shock).
  • Money mindset coaching to help them uncover and shift their “money blocks” to help solve the sticker shock (which made them logically believe they could charge more, but didn’t often translate into actually charging more).
  • Gorgeous proposal templates, consultation and sales call scripts designed to make them feel more confident (yet they still lowered their price before hitting send on that gorgeous proposal).
  • A workshop on how to create credibility and build trust (which had them waiting until they’d done all the things I’d suggested before charging more).
  • And countless hours of coaching on pricing.

And at the end of the program, they’d tell me they loved working with me and were so grateful for everything they’d learned about marketing and getting clients and systems and processes and how to deal with difficult clients and generally running the business side of the web design business…

But then they wouldn’t renew.

And months later I’d hear that they’d joined a competitor’s program.

What a gut punch! I’d given them a ton of resources and great ideas… but I didn’t have a real strategy to help them operationalize and implement the pricing advice I was giving them aside from “Other people charge this much! You can too! Just try it and see what happens!”

Until I randomly met the person who would change everything.

In 2018, a business consultant reached out to me to thank me for a tutorial I created on how to make an Alexa Flash Briefing of all things.

His name was Paul Klein, and we hit it off, and I invited him to be a guest on my old podcast so we could get to know each other better and see what collaboration opportunities there might be.

Paul had spent years helping companies negotiate and structure high-value consulting engagements, from $1,500 projects all the way up to high six-figure contracts, and he shared something in that conversation that cracked everything open for me.

He talked about how when you give a client only one price, they are left to find their own frame of reference for whether it’s worth it, and then they start price shopping.

Which is why he always provided his clients with three options for working together, priced high, medium and low, and in his case as a consultant, with full access to him that reduced as the price went down – because putting those options in front of someone changes the question in their mind from “Should I work with this person?” to “How do I want to work with this person?”

It was a record-scratch moment for me.

It’s not about the price, it’s about how you’re making the offer.

Once I saw it, I couldn’t unsee it.

I immediately saw how this 3-option offer structure would solve so many of the pricing problems my clients had been experiencing: undercharging, overdelivering, overworking, trying to justify prices with case studies and testimonials and messaging to stand out in a saturated market, feeling pressure to pick the right price and lowering it to get the sale, and so much more.

First, I tested applying what Paul shared in my own web design business.

I had a legacy client that was constantly pushing the boundaries and wanting more than what they were paying for, and the “good employee” in me just kept saying yes to keep the client happy and keep some money coming in.

So I decided to test Paul’s 3-option proposal.

I put together options, one of which was to be “on call” for them (which was how I was currently operating) and made that my most expensive option priced at $5,000 per month (which felt astronomical to me at the time) and then gave them a couple of other options that I thought were more in line with their budget.

I presented the options to them, laid out why each option would be a good choice for them, and let them decide – thinking they’d choose one of the cheaper options – because as Paul said during our interview “Pricing is positioning. The high price positions the lower ones as better options.” (and that’s not just Paul’s opinion – it’s backed up by behavioral economics research).

So, I thought for sure they would pick the lowest price.

But I was wrong.

They chose my most expensive option with the most access to me.

Then I put together a different proposal for another client who chose my lowest-priced option, but because I’d structured it to be profitable for me to deliver at that price, it was still a huge win. They saw they had the option to work with me at a deeper level, they didn’t choose it, and I didn’t feel compelled to overdeliver to keep the client happy.

It was like I’d broken free from the Employee Mindset that I didn’t realize had been in the driver’s seat once and for all!

So I started testing what would eventually become known as The Package Matrix™ Method in my Web Designer Academy program, and as we honed the process, our students started reporting back things like “I sold my highest priced offer ever” and “I was shocked when they chose to pay more than what they said their budget was.”

And the best part? They weren’t doing it by hustling to earn the right to charge more.

They were doing it by changing how they made the offer – and charging double, triple, even five times more – on their very next proposal.

The Package Matrix™ Method became the rocket fuel our students needed to make the money they really wanted to be making so they could deliver at a high level for their clients – and resulting in retention, renewals, recurring revenue and referrals for us.

It’s a win-win-win.

So if your clients are leaving because they can’t afford to continue working with you, or leaving and hiring other coaches to help them make more money, or burning out on the delivery side… the unquestioned assumption that they need to earn the right to charge more might be what’s holding them back.

What’s Actually True About Pricing (And Why Your Clients Can Charge More Right Now)

Your clients’ price isn’t about them: their skills, their years of experience, their case studies or how well known they are.

Your clients have a lot more influence over how much they can charge, right now, today, than you or they might think – and more of it comes down to how the decision is put in front of their prospects than you might think.

Every step of the consultation, proposal and offer process can influence whether a prospect says yes or no, how much they choose to spend, and more.

Your clients are decision architects, and a proposal is where they frame the decision – not where they scope the project or make the case for why they’re good enough to charge the price they’ve listed.

And when your clients use science-backed principles of behavioral economics (how humans make decisions about their resources like time and money) in their consultation, proposal and sales process to ethically and intentionally sell higher-ticket projects without having to hustle to prove it, they’ll sell more projects at higher prices.

And it can happen on their very next proposal.

So let’s go back to those five myths and bust them once and for all:

Myth #1: They have to start low and earn the right to charge more. If your client is capable of delivering the result, they get to base their price on the value of the outcome of that result to the client in front of them today, not someday in the future when they’ve delivered that result to enough clients or for a long enough time. They just need a proposal process that sets up a different decision – not “Is this service provider worth paying this much?” but “Is the value of this outcome to me worth more than what this service provider is charging?”

Myth #2: Thought leadership, branding and positioning give them permission to charge more. Credibility work (thought leadership, branding, messaging, positioning) is valuable for what it does: visibility, marketing and lead generation. But it’s not required to be able to charge premium, profitable, sustainable prices. Your client could be charging premium prices on their next referral from a colleague or client before having any of that in place.

Myth #3: They need case studies and testimonials before they can charge more. My student Jen had nearly a decade of experience and case studies in her proposal and was still charging about $6,000. She had no problem getting the number of clients she needed to make the money she wanted to be making – the problem was she’d hit capacity, and she wasn’t interested in growing an agency. Undercharging was not a credibility problem for her – it was a structural, strategic problem. She implemented The Package Matrix™ Method and signed 2 new clients for a total of $77,000 in 7 days (and both clients paid in full).

Myth #4: When they get booked out at a certain price point, then it’s time to raise their prices. That’s just spending a lot of time testing one price point, and putting a lot of pressure on it too! Plus, they’re probably pricing based on faulty assumptions – how much they think it’s worth, how much others in their industry are charging, how much they’d be willing to pay for their service, how much others have paid before… all of which has nothing to do with what the next client is willing to pay!

Your clients are treating their pricing like they’re a huge corporation with tons of customer data that can predict what people will and won’t pay… and the truth is that they are way too small with too small of a sample size to predict what their “target market” will pay – so why not have them strategically test multiple price points on every proposal and see if clients are willing to pay more than they think?

Myth #5: Once they’re seen as an expert, pricing takes care of itself. Visibility can bring more prospects to your clients’ consultation calls, but it doesn’t automatically mean clients will say yes to higher prices. The science of behavioral economics studies how the brain actually makes purchase decisions – not how we think it makes purchase decisions – and your clients’ consultation, proposal and sales processes could be working against how brains make decisions about using their resources (like time and money). Being seen as an expert or thought leader doesn’t automatically solve that problem.

Combine that expertise and thought-leadership with a sales process that works with how brains actually make buying decisions (not how you think they should make buying decisions) – and that’s when your clients become unstoppable.

Resulting in retention, renewals, recurring revenue and referrals for you – and a clear difference from other coaches and consultants in your industry.

When your clients get better results faster, they stay. They renew. They move into your higher level offers.

When you add pricing strategy to your existing methodology and your clients are able to book more projects at higher prices than ever before – it makes working with you pay for itself even faster.

Like Anchor High™ Certified Practitioner Lee, an agency-owner who helps her clients identify roadblocks and bottlenecks to their growth and helps them remove those roadblocks so they can reach their goals.

Lee implemented The Package Matrix™ Method and Anchor High™ Sales Process on behalf of one of her clients – a brand influencer who was just taking whatever flat-rate deals she was being offered from her product partners, hustling hard to create evergreen content for them that was making them a ton of sales while she only got paid once.

Lee Package Matrixed™ her client’s offers and renegotiated brand deals for her that increased her client’s revenue from $10,000 a month to $60,000 a month.

That’s business and life-changing revenue.

And for Lee, the ROI of working with her is crystal clear – because she used to buy into the myth that she needed to hustle to earn it too – which also kept her undercharging and overdelivering for her own clients! Not anymore.

For Lee, The Package Matrix™ Method and the Anchor High™ Sales Methodology was the missing piece of helping her clients create the results she always knew they were capable of!

What to Do Instead of Letting Your Clients Hustle To Earn It

First, don’t buy into their belief that they just need more confidence or to be seen as an expert before they can charge more.

It’s not a confidence problem, it’s a pricing strategy and a proposal structure problem.

Make sure their consultation, proposal and sales process are aligned with how human brains actually make decisions about resources, and that their process isn’t unknowingly working against them.

Once that’s fixed, the rest of it is icing on the cake.

Start by auditing their sales process with these questions:

  • Why did they choose the price they chose? Is it what they think they’re worth? Is it what they think “the market” will pay? Or is it what they know the outcomes are worth to this specific client?
  • What questions are they asking in consultations, and in what order? Are they inadvertently priming an expense-minded decision or an investment-minded one?
  • How many options does the proposal present? Does the proposal set up an ultimatum, or an empowered choice?
  • What’s the first number the prospect sees or hears on the website, the consult intake form, on the consult itself or in the proposal? Could they be setting a low anchor that’s setting their prospect up for sticker shock?
  • Is the proposal written to prove your client is qualified and justify and defend the price, or to pre-frame the value of the outcomes?
  • Are they pricing through their own Hustle or Expense Mindset (“hard work plus more skills equals more money”)?

Then help them fix it with the Anchor High™ Methodology:

  • Help them implement our Consultations That Convert process so they can find out the true value of their service to the client in front of them while asking consultation questions that prime an investment-minded decision.
  • Help them remove any low anchors and language that prime expense-minded decisions, and replace them with high anchors if appropriate.
  • Show them how to explicitly calculate a value-based price, and how to tie their price to the value of the financial, time, emotional and physical outcomes and results for their client (including the cost to that client of doing nothing or delaying moving forward).
  • Show them how to present properly structured and framed options in the proposal to set up an empowered choice with our Package Matrix™ Method.
  • Teach them how to walk a client through a Package Matrix™ the right way with our Anchor High™ Sales Process, so that they sell the treasure, not the map, and create psychological safety for their client to decide.
  • Help them test higher prices on their next few proposals with the new process in place.

Treat credibility work as a marketing and visibility strategy, not a pricing pre-requisite. If you teach branding, messaging, positioning or thought leadership, keep teaching it for what it’s for: marketing and visibility. It’s not required to be able to charge more when you have the right pricing and proposal strategy in place.

And start unlearning the belief that people have to hustle hard and look good to earn it. Building a business absolutely takes time, commitment and effort, and if you can’t deliver on what you say you can deliver, your business won’t succeed… but I’m guessing that’s not you or your clients.

Your clients are brilliant, experienced, great at what they do – and they don’t have to wait to charge more just because now they’re doing it directly for clients instead of for an employer.

Inside my Anchor High™ Certification Program, I teach business coaches, consultants and group program leaders how to spot when a client’s consultation, proposal and sales process is working against how people actually make money decisions, and how to help their clients fix it so they can charge more on their very next proposal.

“But Isn’t the Credibility Work I Teach Still Important?”

It might sound like I think branding, messaging, positioning, case studies and thought-leadership are unimportant or a waste of time…

and that’s not at all what I think!

Those things can absolutely help with visibility, marketing, lead generation and getting consultation calls booked (not to mention having a bigger impact and creating more opportunities for spreading your message and helping more people) – it’s just not a prerequisite for charging more.

Or maybe you’re thinking, “My clients are brand new to business. Don’t they need some proof first before they start charging premium prices?”

If you’re teaching your clients the skills they will be selling (for example, you’re teaching web design to new web designers, or bookkeeping to new bookkeepers), then yes, they need to know how to properly do the thing they’re selling first.

But their newness doesn’t change the fact that the outcomes and results to their clients are valuable – and they can absolutely charge commensurate with the value of the outcomes and results their clients can create at the skill level they can deliver.

Clean books are valuable to a business who needs them to get a business loan, regardless of how long the bookkeeper has been doing it. A website that helps a business book more sales calls is valuable to that business whether it’s the web designer’s first website or 100th.

And what I often see is people who are simply new to business – not new to their expertise – undercharging because they haven’t had to provide their expertise directly to a client before, even though they’ve been doing it for years for their employer.

They don’t need to build credibility first. They just need a framework for charging what they really can and should be charging now.

Your Clients Can Charge More on Their Very Next Proposal

Your clients don’t have to start low, build their thought leadership, collect case studies or wait until they’re seen as an expert to charge more.

Their price is about how the decision is put in front of their prospects, and when you help them redesign that decision with science-backed principles of behavioral economics, they can charge more on their very next proposal.

Ready to Help Your Clients Charge More Now?

Through my Anchor High™ Certification Program, I help business coaches, consultants and group program leaders integrate advanced, science-backed pricing strategies and frameworks into their existing business coaching programs for service providers.

You bring the industry expertise and the clients you already serve.

I bring the pricing and sales methodology designed to help those clients approach their businesses differently.

You don’t have to reinvent your program or start from scratch. You can integrate a proven pricing methodology that complements the incredible work you’re already doing to help your clients succeed.

And in the process, because they’re getting better results, they stay with you, grow with you and send their colleagues to you, which results in higher customer lifetime value and more revenue for your business.

I’d love to help you explore whether Anchor High™ could be the missing piece for your clients.

Fill out this quick form to tell me more about your business and request a zero-pressure info call.

We’ll talk about what it could look like for you to learn the Anchor High™ Methodology and integrate the pricing strategies and frameworks into your coaching program.

Request an Information Call Here!

I can’t wait to meet you!

Pricing, Proposal & Sales Strategy For Freelancers, Fractional Execs & Consultants

ANCHOR HIGH™ PODCAST

Pricing Strategy for Service Providers & Consultants

If you sell your expertise and hands-on implementation, deliver solid work and have happy clients – but you’re maxed out and feel like you’ve hit an income ceiling, this show is for you.

Each short episode breaks down how pricing psychology and proposal strategy influence prospects’ decision-making and helps you rethink everything you thought you knew about how much you can really charge for your services and expertise.

THE PACKAGE MATRIX™ METHOD

The Package Matrix™ Method is a pricing framework built on behavioral economics, sales psychology and a decade of results. It strategically designs a value-based decision for your clients, so you stop pricing based on what you think they can afford and start pricing based on the value they can create by working with you.

How It Works ⟶

ANCHOR HIGH™ CERTIFICATION

If you’re a business coach or consultant who’s an expert at helping your clients grow their businesses and reach their goals – but you don’t have a strategic pricing and sales framework to help your clients confidently close more proposals at higher prices (without working harder), our Anchor High™ Certification program might just be the missing piece of your coaching methodology.

Learn More Here ⟶

ABOUT SHANNON MATTERN

Shannon Mattern is a pricing expert who helps Freelancers, Fractional Execs, Consultants and Creative & Professional Service Providers stop undercharging, overdelivering and overworking by using pricing, proposal and sales strategies backed by behavioral economics and sales psychology.

She helps other business coaches and consultants integrate her pricing and sales methodologies into their coaching, group programs and consultancies so they can help their clients make more without burning out. 

She’s also the founder of Web Designer Academy, where she has spent a decade helping women web designers move from undercharging to premium pricing, and where she developed the offer framework now used by service providers across industries.

Topics

90 DAY REVENUE ROADMAP

Increase your income without rebranding, niching down or adding more services or skills.

RELATED posts

Pricing Education for Business Coaches & Consultants

3 Ways to Help Your Clients Charge More

How business coaches and consultants who work with freelancers, consultants, agencies and other types of service providers can help their clients charge more on their very next proposal by helping them shift from an employee mindset to an expert/entrepreneur mindset, sell the right things, and use science-backed pricing strategies that ethically work with the way people make money decisions.

Read More »
Pricing Education for Business Coaches & Consultants

About Package Matrix™

The Package Matrix™ is an offer framework developed by Shannon Mattern, built on the premise that most service provider pricing failures are decision architecture failures. It structures any service offering into options mapped to pricing paradigms (investment-minded, hustle/hybrid-minded, and expense-minded) so clients make an empowered choice and providers earn more without over-delivering.

Read More »
Pricing Education for Business Coaches & Consultants

The Hidden Pricing Mistakes That Could Be Costing Your Clients Money: What Business Coaches & Consultants Need To Know About Pricing

How business coaches and consultants who work with freelancers, consultants, agencies and other types of service providers can help their clients create better outcomes faster when they help their clients apply proven principles of behavioral economics – the brain science behind why people buy or don’t buy – to pricing and sales strategy and stop treating the symptom of undercharging as a confidence or credibility problem.

Read More »
Pricing Education for Business Coaches & Consultants

Shannon’s Story: The Origin of The Package Matrix™ Method

It’s not about about how much you’re charging – it’s about how you’re making the offer. If you’re struggling with undercharging, overdelivering, overworking, trying to justify prices, trying to compete with other freelancers in the industry and stand out in a saturated market – I’ve been in your shoes, and that’s why I created The Package Matrix™ Method.

Read More »
Why You Don't Need a Portfolio to Charge Premium Prices
Anchor High Podcast

Why You Don’t Need a Portfolio to Charge Premium Prices

You don’t need a portfolio, case studies or thought leadership to charge premium prices. You prove you’re the right fit in the consultation itself, through the questions you ask, and with a paid discovery step that shows the client exactly what you’ll do for them. We’ve helped clients 3x their prices by changing nothing but how they do their proposals, and by charging for the level of service they actually deliver.

Read More »